Our interviewee, Nonnie Cullipher, serves as Implementation Support Manager at the Core Knowledge Foundation. Sherlock Holmes is a legendary fictional detective created by Scottish author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. You can meet him in the Grade 5 Core Classics® Series, free to download here.
Sherlock Holmes: Good day, all. Sherlock Holmes, at your service! In my constant pursuit of facts, evidence, and the occasional elusive truth, I have invited one of the Core Knowledge Foundation team members, Nonnie Cullipher, to assist me in examining a curious modern classroom mystery. And so, as I am fond of saying, “The game is afoot.” *
Nonnie Cullipher: Hello, Mr. Holmes. I’m pleased to be here, and I hope I can provide a little insight.
Sherlock Holmes: “To a great mind, nothing is little.” ** Now then, I have heard the phrase “bringing books back to the classroom,” and it presents a most peculiar puzzle. Did the books vanish? Were they misplaced?
Nonnie Cullipher: Well… not exactly.
Sherlock Holmes: If so, I assure you I have some experience in recovering what others have overlooked!
Nonnie Cullipher: I’m glad to say books never disappeared. I think what you are referring to is a growing conversation in schools about the role of technology in classrooms.
Sherlock Holmes: “It is a capital mistake to theorize before you have all the evidence.” *** And yet, in this instance, Miss Cullipher, your deduction is sound! Tell me, then: do schools now regret the use of these “screens,” as you Americans call them, within the classroom?
Nonnie Cullipher: I’d say it’s more layered than that. Like most classroom decisions, it depends on the students, the lesson, and the purpose. I’m one educator, and there are experts studying this from many perspectives…
Sherlock Holmes: Precisely! Evidence first, conclusion second. Observe the facts, arrange them properly, and the truth will usually reveal itself!
Nonnie Cullipher: In general, the conversation seems to be shifting. It is not really about choosing books or screens. It is about using technology wisely, intentionally, and selectively. Computers can give students access to a wide range of resources, support collaboration, and provide accessibility tools. And of course, students need to be prepared to use technology beyond school.
Sherlock Holmes: Facts! Excellent. Well-ordered facts are as satisfying as a footprint in wet clay.
Nonnie Cullipher: But Mr. Holmes, didn’t you also say, “There is nothing more deceptive than an obvious fact”? **** The obvious fact is that technology can be useful, but there are also concerns.
Sherlock Holmes: Go on!
Nonnie Cullipher: Too much screen time can affect attention, focus, sleep, social development, reading stamina, and mental and physical health. Younger learners already spend a great deal of time on screens outside of school, so many educators are trying to protect and increase time for direct instruction, sustained reading, writing, discussion, and hands-on learning during the school day.
Sherlock Holmes: Intriguing!
Nonnie Cullipher: Yes, and this issue matters just as much in middle and high school. It’s complicated, and educators and parents need to keep learning from research and classroom experience to make the best decisions for students today.
Sherlock Holmes: Quite right. As with any investigation, the answer is rarely as simple as it first appears.
Nonnie Cullipher: Precisely, and speaking of investigations, I’m afraid I must be on my way, Mr. Holmes. I just heard that a long-lost collection of stories about Sir Gus, a brave and honorable knight, has been found in the ruins of an old castle. There’s still so much we don’t know about him, and I, like you, can’t resist a good mystery!
Sherlock Holmes: The case is not closed; we must follow the evidence wherever it leads and attend closely to what enables students to think deeply, collaborate wisely, create with purpose, and communicate with clarity. Teachers and parents, your classrooms are laboratories of thought. May your observations be sharp, your evidence sound, and your conclusions worthy of the case!
Quotes & References
* The Return of Sherlock Holmes, 1905
**A Study in Scarlet, 1887
***A Scandal in Bohemia, 1891
**** The Boscombe Valley Mystery, 1891





